When it’s time for a roof replacement in Wisconsin, many homeowners find themselves choosing between two of the most widely used roofing materials: metal and asphalt shingles. Each offers unique benefits—and important trade-offs—when it comes to performance, durability, maintenance, and cost.
But with Wisconsin’s unpredictable weather, from heavy snow to summer heat, the right decision isn’t always obvious.
This guide breaks down the pros and cons of metal roofing and asphalt shingle roofs, comparing them side by side and evaluating how they stand up to local conditions. Here’s what you need to know before selecting your next roof system.
Key Takeaways
- A metal roof lasts longer and needs less care, while an asphalt roof costs less but wears faster in harsh conditions.
- Metal holds up well against fire, storms, and heat, while asphalt struggles more in snow, wind, and moisture.
- Asphalt fits shorter plans and classic looks while metal adds value, saves energy, and protects against weather.
- A smart roofing choice depends on weather, budget, style, insurance, and honest advice from a local expert.
Comparing Metal and Asphalt Shingles: Feature-by-Feature Breakdown
Choosing between metal and asphalt shingles starts with understanding how each roofing material performs across the features that matter most in Wisconsin. The table below breaks down the key differences to help you compare your options with confidence.
| Features | Metal Roofing | Asphalt Shingles |
| Durability | 40–70 years, high resistance to weather elements | 15–30 years, more prone to wear in extreme weather |
| Initial Cost | Higher initial cost (varies by type of metal) | Lower upfront investment |
| Maintenance | Less maintenance, resists mold and mildew | Requires regular maintenance, especially in humid areas |
| Weight | Lighter than traditional asphalt shingles | Heavier, especially architectural shingles |
| Energy Efficiency | Reflects sun’s UV rays, reduces energy costs | Absorbs heat, higher cooling demands |
| Fire Resistance | Highly fire-resistant, especially the standing seam | Varies by product, but generally less fire-resistant |
| Installation Time | Longer due to labor-intensive fastening | Faster and more common installation |
| Wind Resistance | Excellent—ideal for high winds and storm zones | Can be compromised in areas prone to strong winds |
| Style Options | Standing seam, corrugated, and metal roofing panels | 3-tab and architectural, a wide range of colors |
| Noise Factor | Can be louder during storms unless insulated | Quieter under rain or hail |
| Resale Value | Higher resale value in upscale neighborhoods | Moderate, depending on condition and region |
Metal Roofs: Pros and Cons for Wisconsin Homes
Long-Term Durability for Harsh Midwest Conditions
Metal roofing products are designed to perform under pressure—from heavy snow to extreme weather conditions. A standing seam metal roof is especially ideal for properties in Wisconsin that experience seasonal shifts and unpredictable storm patterns.
Metal panels don’t crack or blister like traditional roofing materials, making them ideal for weather elements that expand and contract with temperature fluctuations.
High Initial Investment with Long-Term ROI
Metal roofs cost more per square foot than asphalt initially. However, the reduced need for a full roof replacement, combined with the roof system’s longevity, makes this investment worthwhile for most homeowners in Wisconsin.
Metal roofing materials like aluminum and steel provide low-maintenance performance, helping offset labor costs over time.
Fire Resistance for Rural and Wooded Properties
Unlike asphalt shingles, metal is non-combustible. A standing seam metal roof offers a Class A fire rating, which is essential for homes near wooded areas or at risk from falling branches and wind-driven debris.
This level of fire resistance can also bring significant insurance benefits, especially in rural zones with fewer fire mitigation resources.
Less Frequent Replacement
Most contractors in Wisconsin recommend metal for its long-term durability. Unlike traditional asphalt shingles that need to be replaced more frequently, metal panels can last well over five decades with minimal maintenance.
That means less disruption from roofing projects over the life of your home.
Energy Efficiency in Sun-Exposed Areas
Wisconsin homes with broad roof exposure can benefit from the energy efficiency of metal roofing. Metal roofing reflects the sun’s UV rays, helping regulate attic temperatures.
For homes exploring solar panels, metal makes installation easier and more secure, offering additional energy cost savings over time.
Asphalt Shingle Roofs: Pros and Cons for Wisconsin Homes
Affordability for Budget-Conscious Homeowners
Asphalt shingles are one of the most common roofing materials used across Wisconsin due to their accessibility and lower asphalt shingles cost per square foot.
Asphalt shingle roofs offer a functional solution for roofing projects in communities where affordability matters without sacrificing performance for most roof types.
Easier Repairs and Faster Installations
Compared to metal, asphalt roofing is less labor-intensive.
For many roofing contractors in Wisconsin, architectural shingles and other common shingle types are quick to install and easy to source. This is especially valuable after storm damage, when a fast tear-off and reroofing job may be needed.
More Frequent Replacement Cycles
Asphalt shingles typically need to be replaced every 15 to 25 years.
In areas prone to high winds or ice, such as eastern Waukesha County, frequent replacement becomes more common. While asphalt remains the most common shingle for Wisconsin roofs, the trade-off is more maintenance and more frequent roof replacement.
Maintenance Demands in Humid Zones
A shingle roof made with asphalt may develop algae or moss in shaded, moisture-rich areas. Regular maintenance becomes necessary, especially in Wisconsin’s wooded residential zones.
Unlike metal, asphalt absorbs moisture and can suffer from much maintenance if neglected.
Lower Fire and Wind Resistance
Traditional roofing materials like asphalt, while cost-effective, don’t perform as well under extreme weather. The fire resistance is typically lower, and the shingles may peel off or degrade under strong winds or storm conditions.
In areas prone to hail and freeze-thaw cycles, asphalt may require roof repairs or patching more often.
How to Decide Between Metal and Asphalt Shingles in Wisconsin
When deciding between metal and asphalt shingles for your Wisconsin home, there’s no one-size-fits-all answer. Below are a few key factors that can help you determine the right roof system for your property, budget, and long-term goals.
Evaluate the Impact of Local Weather
Whether you’re dealing with heavy snow, ice dams, or strong winds off Lake Michigan, your roof type must withstand Wisconsin’s unpredictable climate.
For homeowners in areas prone to temperature extremes, choosing the right materials—metal or asphalt roof—can determine whether your roof stands up to the weather.
Consider Long-Term Budget vs. Short-Term Spend
A new roof is an investment, and roofing options should be weighed against long-term goals.
While asphalt shingles offer short-term savings, a metal roof may reduce frequent replacement and maintenance costs. Over time, choosing low-maintenance materials can ease the financial burden for Wisconsin homeowners.
Assess Your Home’s Curb Appeal and Style
Architectural shingles offer excellent curb appeal for traditional homes in places like Bay View or Shorewood. On the other hand, standing seam metal roofs can elevate the aesthetic of more modern builds, making the roof an integral part of your home’s visual identity.
Review Insurance and Warranty Benefits
Your choice of roofing materials affects not only longevity but also insurance premiums. Many policies offer better terms for homes with fire-resistant metal roofs.
We ensure both asphalt and metal systems are backed by a warranty, giving you confidence in either direction for your roofing project.
Get a Professional Assessment
Deciding between a metal or asphalt roof comes down to your specific property, climate conditions, and plans.
At Allstar Roofing, we provide expert assessments across Wisconsin, guiding most homeowners toward the best roofing materials for their goals—whether that means selecting metal for long-term value or asphalt for affordability and fast installation for a full roof replacement.
Our GAF Master Elite status and 10-year workmanship warranty ensure your roofing project is handled with expert care from start to finish.
Ready to Begin Your Roofing Project?
With over 50 years of craftsmanship and certifications like GAF Master Elite, we back every roof with proven reliability and lifetime guaranteed replacements.
If you’re still weighing the pros and cons of metal vs asphalt shingles, what’s right for your home depends on your location, budget, and goals. Our crew helps Wisconsin homeowners find the best-fit roof system for their property.
Schedule your roofing consultation today or request your full roof replacement estimate with lifetime warranty protection.
Frequently Asked Questions
How does a standing seam metal roof compare to newer composite roof materials in Wisconsin?
A standing seam metal roof lasts longer and handles Wisconsin weather better than most composite roof materials, making it ideal for long-term performance and energy efficiency in demanding climates.
Can I upgrade my asphalt roof to metal without removing the old materials?
Upgrading an asphalt roof to metal is possible in some cases, but we typically recommend a full tear-off to ensure your new roof materials perform properly and meet our workmanship standards.
What other roofing materials are available besides metal and asphalt?
We install other roofing materials such as cedar shakes, slate, and premium synthetics for custom projects, historical homes, or customers who want alternatives to standard asphalt and metal systems.
Are there other materials that help reduce noise better than metal or asphalt roofs?
Yes, other materials like stone-coated steel and synthetic roofing are available. We’ll help you compare options based on comfort, durability, and how they perform alongside asphalt and metal roofs.